Flood Factor in Jacksonville: What That 1–10 Flood Score Means for North Jacksonville Sellers (and Buyers) After Florida Sued First Street

by Chad Dennis, REALTOR®

By Chad Dennis, REALTOR®

Flood Factor in Jacksonville — brick ranch home on a North Jacksonville salt marsh with live oaks, Spanish moss and sabal palms at golden hour
Your Flood Factor in Jacksonville is a private 1–10 score. Your FEMA flood zone is the federal map. Buyers see both. Photo: YourAgentChad / Canva.

A buyer is scrolling listings on a Sunday night. Your house looks great — new roof, fresh paint, the marsh view you fell in love with. Then, a few inches below the photos, a red badge: Flood Factor 8/10, Severe. That buyer may never call. Your Flood Factor in Jacksonville is now part of your listing whether you asked for it or not, and on October 23, 2026, the State of Florida sued the company that produces it.

This matters more in North Jacksonville than almost anywhere in the county. Redfin’s Flood Factor data, as of November 15, 2026, puts 43% of properties in 32226 at risk of severe flooding over the next 30 years, 27% in 32218, 25% in 32225 and 24% in 32219. And the score moves buyers: Zillow’s own research found that in Florida only 35% of high-flood-risk listings from June 2024 had sold by the following March, versus 56% of low-risk listings. In a market where October closed with 5.4 months of supply and 55% of sales carried a seller concession (realMLS), a scary badge is one more reason for a buyer to scroll past.

I’m Chad Dennis, a REALTOR® with eXp Realty, and I live in The Cape in 32226 — canal country, where this score is a kitchen-table topic. This is the plain-English guide to your Flood Factor in Jacksonville: what the number actually measures, how it differs from your FEMA flood zone, what Florida’s lawsuit claims, where buyers see it, and the documents that answer it. Sellers first; buyers, your section is near the end.

Who this is for: Owners in 32218, 32219, 32225 and 32226 listing this winter or spring — especially near the St. Johns, the Broward or Trout rivers, Dunn Creek, Clapboard Creek or the Nassau marsh — and anyone who has looked up their own Flood Factor in Jacksonville and did not like the number. Buyers: skip to section 8.

1. What a Flood Factor in Jacksonville Actually Measures

Flood Factor is a 1-to-10 score made by First Street, a private climate-risk modeling company, and shown on listing sites next to the photos and the school ratings. Every Flood Factor in Jacksonville you see on a listing comes from that one company. It is not a government number. It comes out of the First Street Flood Model, which First Street says weighs elevation, climate, environmental change, proximity to water and adaptation measures for each individual property.

The question the model answers is narrow and specific: what is the chance that at least one inch of water reaches the building footprint of this home, and how deep could it get, over the next 30 years — the life of a typical mortgage? Likelihood and depth together set the score. So your Flood Factor in Jacksonville is a forecast about the slab under your house, not a statement about your street, your neighborhood or your insurance.

How First Street sets a Flood Factor in Jacksonville — the published minimums (source: First Street Help Center, “How is my Flood Factor calculated?”)
Chance of 1 inch of water reaching the footprint, over 30 years Lowest possible score Label buyers usually see
Under 0.2% in every year modeled 1 Minimal
At least 6% 2 or higher Minor (2) to moderate (3–4)
At least 26% 4 or higher Moderate and up
At least 80% 5 or higher Major (5–6) and up
At least 99% 6 or higher; deeper projected water pushes it to severe (7–8) or extreme (9–10) Major, severe or extreme

Two things jump out of that table. First, an 80%-plus chance of water touching the footprint over 30 years guarantees at least a 5 — and from there, the climb toward 9 is driven largely by projected depth, not just odds. Second, First Street itself notes that a Flood Factor of 1 can still flood. The score is a probability, not a promise in either direction.

2. Flood Factor in Jacksonville vs. Your FEMA Flood Zone

This is the part most sellers — and plenty of buyers — get wrong. Your FEMA flood zone and your Flood Factor in Jacksonville are two different measurements made by two different organizations for two different jobs, and they often disagree. First Street says it plainly in its own help center: FEMA zone designations are not an input to the Flood Factor score, and only FEMA maps determine flood insurance and building code requirements.

FEMA flood zone vs. Flood Factor in Jacksonville — side by side
Question FEMA flood zone First Street Flood Factor
Who makes it The federal government (Duval’s current maps took effect November 2, 2018) A private company
What it describes An area of land: A and V zones have a 1% annual chance of flooding; B, C and X are moderate-to-low One building’s footprint, including heavy-rainfall flooding and a 30-year climate projection
Does a lender require flood insurance because of it? Yes — A or V zone plus a federally backed mortgage No
Does it set building and elevation rules? Yes No
Can an owner challenge it? Yes — through FEMA’s map amendment process, usually with an elevation certificate You can submit a dispute, but First Street’s stated rule is that it does not update scores based on individual requests
Where buyers see it FEMA Map Service Center, JaxGIS, the MLS, the seller’s documents Realtor.com and Redfin listings; a click-through link on Zillow; firststreet.org

Why do they disagree so often? FEMA’s maps are built for regulation and mostly look at rivers and coastal surge under today’s conditions. First Street models rainfall flooding and a changing climate, house by house. Neither is a crystal ball. FEMA’s own FloodSmart site notes that from 2014 to 2024 nearly one-third of NFIP flood claims came from outside high-risk areas — which is the gap First Street says it is trying to fill. Florida’s lawsuit argues the opposite problem: scores that call a home a major risk when FEMA calls it minimal.

Pro tip: When a buyer asks about your Flood Factor in Jacksonville, answer with your FEMA zone, your elevation certificate and an actual insurance quote — the three things that decide what flood coverage costs. A score is an opinion about the future; those three are documents.

3. Why Florida Sued First Street — and What It Changes Today

On October 23, 2026, Florida Attorney General James Uthmeier sued First Street Technology in Polk County under the Florida Deceptive and Unfair Trade Practices Act. Here is what the complaint and the coverage of it say, as neutrally as I can put it:

  • The State’s claims. The State says First Street presents its property-level scores as accurate, transparent and scientifically validated when the models carry significant uncertainty; that its flood scores deviate from FEMA’s maps, rating some properties a major risk where FEMA shows minimal hazard; that its “peer-reviewed” and “transparent” claims are misleading because the underlying detail sits behind a paywall; and that owners have no real path to correct a disputed score. The State also argues the scores can affect insurance costs because insurers use First Street data.
  • What Florida is asking for. A jury trial, an injunction barring accuracy, “peer-reviewed” and “transparent” claims made without disclosing uncertainty, consumer redress and civil penalties.
  • Nebraska went first. Nebraska’s attorney general filed a similar suit about two months earlier, alleging scores built on incomplete or incorrect property data that ignore mitigation homeowners have done.
  • First Street’s side. First Street did not immediately respond to reporters’ requests for comment on the suits, and its recent acquirer, MSCI, did not respond either. Its published position is that the model was built by more than 80 scientists, technologists and analysts, went through expert academic panel review and peer-review submission, and was validated against historic flood reports and FEMA flood claims where possible.
  • Outside view. Boston University law professor Madison Condon, quoted in Insurance Journal’s coverage, said she has concerns about how First Street markets its data, but warned a suit like this could chill climate-risk data generally, noting that “scientific models can disagree without being willfully deceptive.”

What it changes for your Flood Factor in Jacksonville today: nothing yet. A lawsuit is an allegation, not a ruling. As of HousingWire’s October 27 check, Zillow, Redfin and Realtor.com were all still showing First Street data or linking to it. If you list this winter, plan on buyers seeing your score — and plan on answering it with paper, not with “the State says it is wrong.”

4. Where Buyers See Your Flood Factor in Jacksonville

The display rules have shifted over the past year, and they matter for how you prepare your Flood Factor in Jacksonville answer:

  • Zillow removed the climate scores from its listing pages in late November 2025, after the California Regional MLS questioned their accuracy. Buyers can still click through to First Street’s data from the listing.
  • Realtor.com kept the scores but stopped showing percentage predictions for flood risk, per The Wall Street Journal’s January 2026 reporting.
  • Redfin still shows the ratings. Its chief economist defended keeping them because homebuyers find climate risk scores valuable. Redfin also publishes ZIP-level Flood Factor shares on its housing-market pages — that is where the North Jacksonville percentages in this post come from.
  • Seller requests. The Journal reported that Redfin removes a score at a home seller’s request, and that a seller’s score was removed from Redfin and Realtor.com when he asked. Neither company publishes a formal process; Redfin has said sellers can ask its customer service team.
  • firststreet.org shows a basic score for any address to anyone who types it in — removing the badge from a listing does not remove the score from the internet.

One more lesson from the Journal’s reporting: errors happen. One seller’s report was tied to the wrong address; after the paper asked, First Street corrected it from 9 to 7 and blamed one of its data providers. Before you list, look up your own Flood Factor in Jacksonville on firststreet.org and make sure the pin is on your roof, not the neighbor’s lot by the creek.

5. The North Jacksonville Flood Factor Numbers

Here is what Redfin’s First Street data shows for our four ZIPs, read on November 15, 2026. “At risk” means the share of properties with a meaningful chance of severe flooding over the next 30 years. These are ZIP-level averages, not the Flood Factor in Jacksonville on any one house.

Flood Factor in Jacksonville by ZIP — North Jacksonville (Redfin housing-market pages, First Street data, read Nov. 15, 2026)
ZIP Area ZIP rating Share at risk (30 yrs) Properties
32226 The Cape, New Berlin, Black Hammock Island, Heckscher Drive Severe 43% 2,734
32218 Oceanway, Jamestown, Pecan Park Moderate 27% 2,976
32225 Ft. Caroline, Girvin, Kernan north Moderate 25% 2,986
32219 Westport, Garden City Moderate 24% 930

Read that with care. A ZIP-wide share is an average across very different lots — a 32226 home on a bluff in Eagle Bend and a 32226 home on a tidal creek off Heckscher Drive are not the same risk, and they will not carry the same Flood Factor in Jacksonville. The parcel-level answer is your FEMA panel and your elevation certificate; the ZIP number just tells you how often buyers in your area will run into the topic.

Why the score bites harder in this market

Buyers have choices right now. realMLS Market Insights for 32218, 32219, 32225 and 32226 (single-family, condo and townhome; dashboard updated November 14, 2026) shows October with 915 active listings and 5.4 months of supply, up from 4.6 a year earlier. Well-priced homes still moved — median days on market was 33, and 14.2% sold over list — but 55% of closings carried a seller concession, at a median of $10,800.

In a market with five-plus months of supply, a buyer who sees a red score on your listing and a gray one on the house two streets over has an easy alternative. Zillow’s national research found that among June 2024 listings, 52% of high-flood-risk homes had sold by the following March versus 71% of low-risk homes, and the flood-prone homes that sold went for about 6% under their initial list price versus about 3% for low-risk homes. Your job as a seller is to make sure your Flood Factor in Jacksonville is never the only flood information a buyer has.

6. The Seller’s Playbook for a High Flood Factor in Jacksonville

You cannot change the model behind your Flood Factor in Jacksonville. You can control everything around it. Here is the order I would work it, starting this week if you plan to list before spring:

Step 1 — Look it up yourself, and check the pin

Type your address into firststreet.org and into your home’s Redfin and Realtor.com pages. Write down your Flood Factor in Jacksonville, the label, and whether the map pin sits on your house. A wrong-address or wrong-footprint error is the one problem First Street has fixed when it was pointed out publicly.

Step 2 — Pull your FEMA zone and your elevation certificate

Look up your parcel on FEMA’s Map Service Center or JaxGIS. If you are in X, say so in the listing packet — that is a federal “moderate-to-low risk” designation, and the lender will not require flood insurance. If you are in A or AE, request your elevation certificate; the City of Jacksonville’s floodplain office keeps copies of existing ones. I covered zones, certificates and the City’s discount in detail in the flood chapter of the pre-listing inspection guide.

Step 3 — Get a real flood insurance quote

The scariest version of a Flood Factor in Jacksonville is the one with no dollar sign attached. Ask your agent for a current NFIP quote and a private-market quote on the home as it stands. If you already carry flood insurance, put the declarations page in the packet — an NFIP policy can be assigned to your buyer at closing. Jacksonville is a Community Rating System Class 6 community, which earns NFIP policyholders a 20% discount inside the high-risk zone and 10% outside it.

Step 4 — Document what you have done to the house

Nebraska’s lawsuit specifically argues that First Street’s scores often miss mitigation owners have done. Whatever the model sees, a buyer can only credit what you show them: a raised slab, flood vents, an elevated AC condenser and water heater, regraded drainage, a French drain, gutters with extensions, a seawall in good repair. Photos and invoices go in the packet. If the home has never taken water in your ownership, that is part of your statutory flood disclosure anyway (section 7). That paper is what a buyer weighs against your Flood Factor in Jacksonville.

Step 5 — Decide whether to ask the portals to hide the badge

Per The Wall Street Journal, Redfin removes a score at a seller’s request and Realtor.com has honored a seller request. It is your call, and there is a fair argument either way. Hiding the badge keeps a first impression off the listing; it does not hide the score from firststreet.org, and it does not change a single disclosure duty. My view: do it only after your packet is ready, so the first flood information a curious buyer finds is your documents, not a blank space.

Step 6 — Put the answer in the listing, not just the packet

One line of MLS remarks — “FEMA Flood Zone X; no flood claims during ownership; elevation certificate and insurance quote available” — answers the badge before the buyer’s agent has to ask. Hand the packet to every showing agent. Then price off the full picture: a high Flood Factor in Jacksonville on a home with an X zone, a dry history and a $600 quote is a very different negotiation from one with an AE zone and no paperwork.

Pro tip: Never write “not in a flood zone” in a listing unless the FEMA map says X and you have checked it for your parcel. “Flood Zone X per FEMA panel [number]” is accurate, specific and hard to argue with — and it is the strongest answer to a high Flood Factor in Jacksonville.

7. Flood Factor in Jacksonville and Your Disclosure Duty

Florida’s flood disclosure law and your Flood Factor in Jacksonville are separate things, and mixing them up can cause trouble on either side.

Under Florida Statute 689.302, every residential seller must give the buyer a written flood disclosure at or before contract. Since the 2025 amendment took effect October 1, 2025, it asks whether you know of flooding that damaged the property during your ownership, whether you have filed any flood-damage insurance claim, and whether you have received flood-damage assistance from any source, including FEMA. It does not ask about your Flood Factor in Jacksonville, and a low score does not excuse a flood you know about. Florida Realtors publishes the form; I bring it to every listing appointment.

The flip side: a high score is not a defect you must “disclose” as if it were a known problem with the house. It is publicly visible third-party data. What you must never do is misrepresent — tell a buyer the home “can’t flood,” or answer a direct flood-history question with anything but the truth. Answer your Flood Factor in Jacksonville with facts, answer the disclosure form honestly, and let your documents carry the weight. For legal questions on a specific property, talk to a Florida real estate attorney.

8. What Actually Sets Your Buyer’s Flood Cost

Your buyer’s monthly payment is what moves their offer, and flood insurance can be part of it. The things that drive that number are federal and contractual, not your Flood Factor in Jacksonville:

  • FEMA zone. An A or V zone plus a federally backed mortgage means required flood insurance. FEMA says homes in those zones have about a 1-in-4 chance of flooding at least once over a 30-year mortgage.
  • NFIP pricing. Under Risk Rating 2.0, FEMA prices each building’s risk; an elevation certificate is optional but can lower the premium.
  • December 11, 2026. The National Flood Insurance Program is authorized only through December 11. It has been extended 36 times since 2017 and lapsed twice in the past year — October 1 to November 12, 2025, and February 1–3, 2026. During a lapse FEMA cannot sell new policies or renewals, which can stall a closing that needs one. Existing policies stay in force, and an assignable policy is worth gold. I wrote more in the 7% rates post.
  • January 1, 2027. Every remaining Citizens personal residential policyholder must carry flood coverage starting January 1, 2027. A buyer who ends up with Citizens will be buying flood insurance whatever the FEMA zone says.

Insurers do use First Street data in some models — that is part of Florida’s argument — so a score can show up indirectly in a private quote. That is exactly why Step 3 above matters: a real quote replaces speculation about what your Flood Factor in Jacksonville “might” cost with a number.

9. Buyers: How to Read a 9/10 Flood Factor in Jacksonville

If you are house-hunting in North Jacksonville — including the NAS Jacksonville and Naval Station Mayport families who will be shopping here through winter — here is how to use the score without letting it make the decision for you:

  • Treat it as a question, not an answer. A high Flood Factor in Jacksonville tells you to look harder. It does not tell you the house floods, and a low one does not tell you it won’t.
  • Get the FEMA zone and the elevation certificate. The zone decides whether your lender requires flood insurance; the certificate shows how high the floor sits above the base flood elevation.
  • Read the seller’s flood disclosure before you write an offer. Florida sellers must disclose known flooding, flood claims and flood assistance during their ownership.
  • Get a bindable insurance quote inside your inspection period — homeowners and flood. If the number does not work, the “AS IS” contract’s inspection period is when you can still walk away.
  • Look with your own eyes. Drive the street after a heavy rain. Look at where the yard drains, whether the AC and water heater sit up off the ground, and how the lot sits relative to the road and the nearest creek — no Flood Factor in Jacksonville can show you how a street drains.
  • VA buyers: the lender will require flood insurance in an A or V zone just like a conventional lender. Ask early whether the seller’s policy can be assigned.

If you are weighing resale against new construction, newer subdivisions were permitted under the current floodplain rules — but check each lot’s zone and elevation anyway. I compare the two paths in the quick move-in homes guide.

10. The North Jacksonville Market Behind Every Flood Factor in Jacksonville

The October numbers, so the advice has context. realMLS Market Insights, four-ZIP North Jacksonville group, single-family plus condo and townhome, dashboard updated November 14, 2026.

North Jacksonville, October 2026 vs. October 2025 — the market every Flood Factor in Jacksonville is selling into (realMLS Market Insights, accessed through the author’s REALTOR® membership)
Metric Oct 2026 Oct 2025 What it means for a high score
Median sale price $329,500 $330,000 Flat — buyers are not paying up for risk
Months of supply 5.4 4.6 More alternatives for a buyer who scrolls past
Active listings 915 958 Fewer listings, but closings fell faster (169 vs. 209)
Days on market (median) 33 37 Prepared, well-priced homes still sell quickly
Closings with a seller concession 55.0% 45.0% Buyers ask for help — often to cover insurance and closing costs
Median concession $10,800 $10,000 The number a good flood packet helps you protect
Estimated median monthly payment (PITI) $2,585 $2,347 Up 10% — every insurance dollar counts in the buyer’s math

Rates: Freddie Mac’s 30-year average was 7.18% on November 5, 2026, down three weeks in a row but still well above the 6.22% of a year earlier. At a 7-handle, buyers are precise about the monthly payment, and flood insurance is part of it. A seller who can show a real quote takes the guesswork out of that line — and out of the Flood Factor in Jacksonville conversation. I go deeper on how concessions are priced in the seller concessions guide.

Worried about your Flood Factor in Jacksonville? Let’s build the answer before you list.

I will look up your score, your FEMA zone and your elevation certificate with you, walk the lot, and put together the flood packet buyers’ agents actually read — so the badge on your listing is never the whole story. You always come first, I answer my phone, and I do whatever it takes to get you to the closing table without the stress.

📞 Call or text: 904-977-5509

🌐 seealllistings.homes

“Your Realtor® ~ Your Advocate”

11. Flood Factor in Jacksonville: FAQ

What does a Flood Factor of 9/10 mean?

A Flood Factor of 9 or 10 is First Street’s “extreme” category. It means the model projects a high chance that at least one inch of water reaches the home’s building footprint over the next 30 years, combined with deep projected flooding. It is a private forecast, not a FEMA designation, and it does not by itself require flood insurance. For a Flood Factor in Jacksonville at that level, check the FEMA zone, the elevation certificate, the seller’s flood disclosure and a real insurance quote before deciding what it means for that house.

What does a Flood Factor of 1/10 mean?

A Flood Factor of 1 is “minimal” risk: First Street’s model shows less than a 0.2% chance of flood water reaching the building footprint in each year analyzed. First Street notes that Flood Factor 1 properties can still flood. A low Flood Factor in Jacksonville is common on higher ground away from creeks, but it is not a substitute for checking the FEMA flood zone or asking the seller about flood history.

Is Flood Factor the same as a FEMA flood zone?

No. A FEMA flood zone is the federal designation that decides whether a lender requires flood insurance and which building rules apply. Flood Factor is a private 1–10 score from First Street that models each building, including heavy-rainfall flooding and a 30-year climate projection. First Street says FEMA zones are not an input to Flood Factor and that only FEMA maps set insurance and building requirements. A home can be in FEMA Zone X and still carry a high Flood Factor in Jacksonville, or the reverse.

Can a seller remove a Flood Factor score from a listing?

The Wall Street Journal reported in January 2026 that Redfin removes a climate score at a home seller’s request and that Realtor.com removed a seller’s flood score when he asked; Zillow stopped showing the scores on listing pages in late 2025 and links out instead. Removing the badge does not remove the score from firststreet.org and does not change a seller’s flood disclosure duty. First Street’s stated policy is that it generally does not change a Flood Factor in Jacksonville or anywhere else based on individual disputes.

Why is Florida suing First Street?

On October 23, 2026, Florida Attorney General James Uthmeier sued First Street Technology in Polk County under the Florida Deceptive and Unfair Trade Practices Act. The State alleges the company presents its climate-risk scores as accurate, transparent and peer-reviewed without disclosing their uncertainty, that some flood scores contradict FEMA maps, and that owners cannot correct disputed scores. Nebraska filed a similar suit earlier. First Street has not commented publicly on the suits; its published position is that its model was peer-review submitted and validated against flood claims. As of late October, listing sites still showed or linked to the scores, so the suit does not change any Flood Factor in Jacksonville today.

Does a high Flood Factor mean I need flood insurance?

Not by law. Lenders require flood insurance on federally backed mortgages when the home is in a FEMA high-risk zone (A or V), regardless of the Flood Factor. That said, FEMA reports that nearly one-third of NFIP claims from 2014 to 2024 came from outside high-risk areas, and starting January 1, 2027, every Citizens personal residential policyholder must carry flood coverage. A high Flood Factor in Jacksonville is a good reason to get a quote even when it is not required.

About the author

Chad Dennis is a REALTOR® with eXp Realty serving North Jacksonville — 32218, 32219, 32225 and 32226 — and a U.S. Army veteran who bought his own home with a VA loan. He holds the Military Relocation Professional (MRP) and New Home Certified Professional designations, lives in The Cape, and writes the North Jacksonville real estate blog for sellers and buyers who want the numbers before the pitch. If your Flood Factor in Jacksonville worries you, he will help you build the answer.

Related guides: Pre-listing inspection in Jacksonville · 5 mistakes North Jacksonville sellers make · What your North Jacksonville home is worth · Best neighborhoods in North Jacksonville · Search every North Jacksonville listing

Sources: First Street — How is my Flood Factor calculated?; First Street — Disputing Property Scores; HousingWire, Oct. 27, 2026; Insurance Journal, Oct. 27, 2026; ESG Dive; The Wall Street Journal, “The Climate-Disaster Scores That Could Make or Break Your Home Sale,” Jan. 18, 2026; Zillow Research, Mar. 12, 2025; Redfin housing-market pages for 32226, 32218, 32225 and 32219, read Nov. 15, 2026.

Also: FEMA FloodSmart — What’s Your Flood Risk?; FEMA Flood Map Service Center; Congressional Research Service on the Dec. 11, 2026 NFIP deadline; Florida Realtors on the expanded flood disclosure; City of Jacksonville Floodplain Management; Citizens flood coverage requirement; Freddie Mac PMMS; realMLS Market Insights accessed through the author’s REALTOR® membership, Nov. 15, 2026. This post is general information, not legal or insurance advice; confirm requirements with your carrier and a Florida attorney.

#FloodFactor #JacksonvilleRealEstate #NorthJacksonville #32226 #32218 #32225 #32219 #FloodInsurance #FloodZone #SellingAHome #HomeBuyerTips #YourAgentChad

Chad Dennis
Chad Dennis

Agent SL3638791 FL

+1(904) 977-5509 | chad.dennis@seealllistings.homes

GET MORE INFORMATION

Name
Phone*
Message